Witches Like Beer and Pilgrims Like Pie.

When you can’t find time to comb your own hair you realize, perhaps, one should slow down. But there are so many fun things to see and do and eat-places to go and books to read-so, for the record, Dreadlocks are back in style! (I know all 10 of my good friends who are hairdressers and stylists are getting ready to blow up my phone with angry texts 🙂 )

Yes, I did wait till 6 days before Halloween to post the Halloween menu but I am also EARLY with the Thanksgiving menu and for that there should be at least a 1/2 point awarded.

We are, frankly, astounded at how busy September and October were. I have been working on this Island since 1997 and I have never seen it this busy. It’s so fun! It’s almost like full-time town now. #teatuesday is going well-and while a few grumble that it is only beverages and books on Tuesday, most seem content with being able to amble about with a beverage and peruse the stacks on an otherwise mundane day.

We have packed the store with our take on Halloween necessities and pumpkin perfection! This week all Halloween books, new and used are 31% off. We have some FANTASTIC witch books and ghost stories in there!! Ruth Chewwednesday-witch (The ednesday WitchBetty MacDonald (Mrs. Piggle Wiggle). Our indomitable Claudia made some super-adorable Halloween signage from Island salvaged pallets-forgo the mass-produced “made in China” one’s they are hawking at Home Goods- and Lumina boo Embroidery made the CUTEST candy corn bibs!

Halloween Specials

Pumpkin Pie-$16

Goblin Green Key Lime Pie-$15

Blackbeard Pierummy, rum, rum cheesecake pie topped with a rich blackberry compote spiked with more Captain Morgan’s Rum $18

SpiderWeb Macaroons-our house coconut macaroon decorated with chocolate spiderwebs $2.25

Spooky Ghosts Sugars-sparkling white sugar cookie ghosts $1.65

Pumpkin Whoopies-mini or large $2/$3.50

Pumpkin Nut Bread-$10

Pumpkin Chocolate Chip Bread $10

Pumpkin Layer Cake-$25 3 layer pumpkin cake filled and frosted with cream cheese frosting and garnished with wee pumpkins

Cadbury Scream Cupcakes-people wait ALL year for this super-chocolatey candy filled cupcake! Our chocolate cupcake stuffed and topped with a Cadbury scream egg! $3.50 each

Dead Velvet Cake-the ONLY time of year we do red velvet!! deep red and rich red velvet cake frosted with cream cheese frosting available in white or PURPLE frosting topped with tiny edible witch hats $30

Trick or Treat Box-box of 9 assorted spooky Halloween cupcakes-$18-


This slideshow requires JavaScript.

Sneak Peak at Thanksgiving!! We are having a pre-holiday show on Saturday, November 12, that is going to be 50’s themed and Kookie cool, Daddy-o!!!

Pre-order the much-awaited Rogue Creamery Blue ReserveGrand Cru and incomparable Heirloom Apples. Full menu will be loaded later but here is a rapid fire sampling. Make sure to sing the menu to the tune of “We Didn’t Start the Fire” by Billy Joel! Honeyed Cornbread, White or Wheat Bread, Cranberry Jam Bars, Ginger Chews, Cranberry Oatmeal Cookies, Turkey Sugars, Cranberry Orange Poundcake, Gingerbread, Pumpkin Bread, Pumpkin Cake, Pilgrim Cake, Caramel Apple Cake, Sweet Potato Cheesecake Swirl, Cherry Pie, Pecan Pie, Pumpkin Pie, Chocolate Boubon Pie….

.”We didn’t start the diet!!! It ways always yummy and the pies are scrummy! We didn’t start the diet because you can’t be rude when they’re serving foooooood…”Billy Joel sing!!!


You know the drill, PRE-ORDER.  sugarislandnc@gmail.com 910.254.1110




Published by sugaronfrontst

Bookstore/Bakery/Microfarm in the South!

One thought on “Witches Like Beer and Pilgrims Like Pie.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: